[Doohickey]

Joey’s got adult ADD and thinks whatever he’s looking at right now is the greatest. Not to take anything away from Tom Brady, because he is great. If Dan Marino had even one ring we wouldn’t even be having this discussion. Here are five QBs I think were better than Tom Brady, ring count notwithstanding:

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Troy Aikman
4. Dan Marino
5. Steve Young

[allmendream]

Your #1 and #5 are the same as crazydad! Growing up it was a fun time for my hometown team to be the 49’ers during the heyday of the Montana Rice last minute scoring drives!

I would pick the same #1 as you as well. Given a random NFL team against random NFL opponents with 2 minutes left on the clock and down by 6. If your time machine could pick any of the QB’s mentioned at their prime.........who WOULDN’T pick Joe Montana?

[fhayek]

If Marino had even one ring? Yeah if only I had a million dollars, I’d be rich. I’m a Bills fan. We faced the Dolphins twice a year. I would not have traded Marino for Jim Kelly straight up. No way is Marino the greatest.