If you live close enough to your college, go have lunch in the cafeteria where you met. I bet if you call ahead and tell them the story, someone would be willing to surprise her with a couple of cupcakes with candles.
Then go to the library and make out in the stacks (Don’t tell me you never did).
The college is about 700 miles west of where we now live. A bit of a drive for cafeteria food!
As far as the stacks go....I’m not sayin’ =)