This is what the religion moderator has on her/his homepage.
As much as is possible I try to use a progressive method with uncooperative Religion Forum posters a warning, and if that warning is ignored, a cookie (making him log in again), and if that is ignored, an hour suspension and so on up to a banishment. I do this because an occasional misstep on such sensitive matters as ones confession should be tolerable. But I will not be ignored.
Posters who have been previously banned and try to come back with a different handle will be banished as soon as they are found out. Some retreads stay off the radar by behaving themselves, but once they start picking fights they cause the moderators any of us to investigate. If you have been previously banned and want to come back on the forum, make a request, promise not to do whatever caused the first banning.
A poster may also be banned in an instant if he is discovered to be a racist, a hate monger including an anti-Semitist, troll, anti-Freeper, etc.
There will be people on the forum who are anti- your confession whether anti-Christian, anti-Calvinist, anti-Catholic, anti-Protestant, anti-Mormon, anti-Atheist, anti-Scientologist and so on. As long as they are arguing for their position on an Open thread and are not using hate mongering material such as the false oath for Knights of Columbus or Jack Chick cartoons and are otherwise abiding by the guidelines, their challenges will be tolerated.
Threads that become toxic which is to say have devolved into an unredeemable mess of hurt feelings will be locked or pulled. I prefer to lock the threads because many posters put a great deal of effort in their replies and would like to keep them bookmarked.
Sounds reasonable to me. More than that, it is compassionate.