[JillValentine]

Peih-Gee and Jamie made a bold move, but they made several mistakes while doing so - being too obvious about throwing the challenge, giggling instead of making it look like a serious strategic move, and failing to tell Erik about their plan beforehand. Something about young women giggling seems to inspire wrath among men and older women. Oh well. I don't giggle all that much.

On the plus side, it's done wonders for interest in the show - this thread got a lot noisier all of a sudden!

"That's classic Mike, he's an idiot." - Jeff Varner, Survivor: Australia

[Collier]

Since the girls didn’t tell Erik about the plan to throw the challenge, I was surprised that he didn’t team up with James and Aaron and get rid of the girls, one at a time.
Erik seemed quite annoyed.
It seems that James and Aaron didn’t even approach Erik with that idea.