[cdcdawg]

I can’t see Vick in the top anything, much less the top 15. He and Eli Manning are ranked too high.

[rock_lobsta]

I'm with you on Eli, but Vick (if he stays out of prison) will get you 2300 yds passing and 21 TDS. That's pretty average - he puts up too many turnovers, IMO.

However, I'm not including his rushing numbers. The additional 800 yds rushing and 5 scores on the ground is what makes Vick valuable.

Just make sure you're not on any heart medication...

I've never had Vick on any of my teams, but he makes a good QB2 on your roster. I just wouldn't pick him as a QB1, or before the 10th round. You can always count on someone reaching for him in round 5...

[Dante3]

First it was a woman suing Vick for getting herpes. Now the Humane Society is after him in the dog fighting scandal. Horrific the condition of some of the dogs found at his place. Wasn’t he also investigated in regards to drugs?