[auboy]

It was a mistake to ever let Sanjaya get to Hollywood - a really bad move by the judges.

[Nathan Jr.]

It was a mistake to ever let Sanjaya get to Hollywood - a really bad move by the judges.

Don't forget they also chose him for the final 24.

[spectre]

If Idol survives to go another season, the Judges should think very hard about giving a no talent contestant a pass to Hollywood.

I blame all three Judges for this mess because they thought it was "cute" to give the guy a pass.

Besides ruining Idol's credibility, they gave the College crowd a new "hobby"... voting for the "worst" contestant to win.

sw

[over3Owithabrain]

It was a mistake to ever let Sanjaya get to Hollywood - a really bad move by the judges.

The AI braintrust doesn't see it that way. The show generally stinks this season and ratings are down. The Sanjaya angle has been about the only buzz the show is getting and thus keeping it as water-cooler discussion.