[randita]

As an Eagles fan, I have no confidence in McNabb to win the must-win game. He's a great quarterback, exciting to watch and can make unbelievable plays, but I don't know if he has what it takes to perform at top level when it REALLY, REALLY matters.

I also wonder if his best years are behind him.

[Perdogg]

He has had 3 major injuries in 6 seasons. He pretty much choked against the Buccs (2003) and Panthers (2004).

I think his problem is that he has never adapted to the pro game. He needs to stay in the pocket, and not get impatient, and be a PRO QB.

FTR, I am a Dallas fan. Sometimes fans of opposing teams can provide unique prospective.

[fnord]

the constant bleating about McNabb being one of the top QBs actually proves Rush was right, but don't expect the media to ever admit that.