It's hard to go wrong with any of the Fuentes.
I quite agree! I'm a big fan of the brand, and have smoked many of the Gran Reservas and Hemingways and have found the quality very consistent. Yesterday, I had a Fuente Reserva Añejo, and it was just wonderful.
Mr. Adams and I appear to share a taste for "full-bodied" cigars. I've had several on his list, and of those the La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero stands out as one I found almost too powerful. If you haven't tried them, the Rocky Patel "Edge" line is quite good (and a real bargain at $4-5 a stick), although I prefer the Maduro to the Corojo.
Finally, one serious omission in my mind from the "Top 10" has to be the Padron Serie 1926 40th Anniversario Maduro - easily a "95" rating in my book, but pricey, too ($20-25 each, if you can find one). Obviously, it's for special occasions only (unless money is no object), and well worth the expense.