[Mr. Mojo]

Nope, not even at their peaks. Check out Joe Ds three best years (although he had a few more years with similar numbers):

1937: .346 BA, .673 SLG%, 46 HRs, 167 RBIs, 37 strikeouts.
1939: .381 BA, .671 SLG%, 30 HRs, 126 RBIs, 20 strikeouts
1940: .352 BA, .626 SLG%, 31 HRs, 133 RBIs, 30 strikeouts

Give me Murphy's three best years and we'll stack 'em up.

(And also remember that teams played 8 fewer games per season in Joe D's era).

As far as outfield prowess is concerned, Murphy was good, but Joe D was among the top five to ever play the game.

[TheBigB]

I'll bow to Joe D. Murph's number can't compare to those.

I still think he's a HoFer, though. At least, he should get more support than he does.