HRs per 162 games: Joe D 34, Murphy 30
RBIs per 162 games: Joe D 143, Muphy 94 (an embarrassing discrepancy)
RBIs total: Joe D 1537, Murphy 1266
Hits per 162 games: Joe D 207, Murphy 157 (another embarrassing discrepancy)
Doubles per 162 games: Joe D 36, Murphy 26
Triples: Joe D 131, Murphy 39 (ouch)
Strikouts per 162 games: Joe D: 34, Murphy 130 (double ouch)
On base %: Joe D .398, Murphy .346
Slugging %: Joe D .579, Murphy .469
.....the embarrassing comparison goes on, and on, and on....
I think at their respective peaks, Murph was a comparable all-around player. Certainly his career numbers don't match up, I know.