Which one of them, John or Patsy, raped her with the blunt end of a paint brush and why do you think they felt this was necessary?
If you bothered to read what I actually wrote here and and here, you'd see that I never suggested that. What I theorized is little different than what post #114, and post #173 have also suggested. Karr may prove to be a crackpot, and I'd still hold to my theory.