I really don't care what you think. People who are not completely ignorant of biology will recognize at least one ludicrous error in the scenario in post number one. People who don't see it and yet continue to think they are smart enough to overturn hundreds of years of science are simply nuts.
Nevermind.
Imagine that evolution is driven by magic elves, with the power to mutate genes, and create new species. But everyone knows there's no such thing as magic elves, so therefore evolution is false.
Which line do I stand in to collect my Nobel prize?