[retrokitten]

I think the ring may be more important then we think. I have HBP on cd and am listening to it, too. I'm just to Harry and Dumbledore's first journey into the pensive (sp?).

Someone posted this link the other day...HBP is the Best HP Novel and they raise some interesting questions. Just a warning, it's really, really, really long.

[andyssister]

I think the ring may be more important then we think

I agree. When Marvolo Gaunt is wearing it, it's not cracked. When DD has it, it's cracked.

Maybe this is to show us that a horcrux vessel can remain fairly intact when the soul piece is removed? (Ala Harry??) Just a thought...

Thanks for the link. If I'm not on FR, I'm on Hogwarts Professor or HP Lexicon. total loser!! :)