Well, they missed 4 unpolished ones...
So which are which?
I believe the warrant specified red fingernails. If so, they could not take unpolished fingernails, could they?
The 5 fingernails in the warrant have to be the ones the Lax players in the trash and then took out and gave to the police.
Just checked, the warrant does specify fingernails with a reddish polish. That may be why the unpolished ones were left.