[commish]

Eliot just won the night for me... Amazing vocals!!!!

Quick rating:
1. Eliot 2. bucky 3. Kellie 4. taylor 5. mandisa 6. Chris 7. lisa 8. Paris 9. Katherine 10. Ace

This was by far the absolute worst Idol ever.

[Echo Talon]

Quick rating: 1. Eliot 2. bucky 3. Kellie 4. taylor 5. mandisa 6. Chris 7. lisa 8. Paris 9. Katherine 10. Ace

Switch around Chris and Kellie.

[TonyWpi]

My rating is pretty close, except I'd put McPhee up a lot higher...

1) Elliott Mr. Tumnus
2) McPhee
3) Bucky
4) Mandisa
5) Taylor
6) Chris
7) Kellie May
8) Lisa
9) G'Ace
10)Paris

[Always Right]

You list looks pretty good, although I don't think Katherine should be that far down. There were several worse performances. I do think Ace is in real trouble.

[I'm ALL Right!]

Based on performances tonight, here is how I would place them...

1. Elliot
2. Taylor
3. Mandisa
4. Paris
5. Katherine
6. Chris
7. Bucky
8. Ace
9. Kellie
10. Lisa