[Wyatt's Torch]

Pickler (or anyone) should be eliminated solely for doing a Celine Dion song.....If they sing the one from Titanic they should not only be automatically eliminated but also shot on sight.

I'm not sure I buy Chris's choice. VERY obvious. Same with Taylor. Too predictable. I don't buy the list.

[Netizen]

I agree. We usually don't good spoilers til about an hour before the show.

[Kimberly GG]

Pickler (or anyone) should be eliminated solely for doing a Celine Dion song.....If they sing the one from Titanic they should not only be automatically eliminated but also shot on sight. "

I was going to say the exact same thing about the Katharine/Houston attempt.

IMO, many of the contestants have chosen songs that I unfamiliar with, and thus don't really enjoy, or they pick the stuff like Houston/Dion and are admonished for it. Is there no middle ground?

Taylor Hicks is my choice regardless. I think most people already have their minds made up.