Hi Hildy. Not always. Simon often is contradictory and inconsistent in his comments to the contestants. But then maybe this is a matter of something being in the eye of the beholder.
I was thinking. Last night was a good night for all but Ace and Pickles. It was also a good night for the judges. Paula didn't seem drunk. Do you suppose she gets snockered when the show is going to stink, just to make it through?
I guess in comparison to the other judges his critiques border on brilliance. But that's not saying too much! Paula Abdul gets more bizarre every week. And someone should teach Randy a few more adjectives.