How can you not love this guy....I thought he did great last night...one of the posters thought he was a little boring in the beginning but i just went back and listened to his performance and I liked it start to (almost) finish...I think he was running out of gas at the end but overall, he's still going on! Simon was right - it was Magic so I'm not understanding the comment to Kat about all other performances being amaturish compared to her's. If he doesn't win, I believe it will be Chris....I'm not into the yelling rocker thang...I love the songs (other than Country Road) Taylor's picked and I've been very happy with him from the original audition until last night! I need to find a Soul Patrol t-shirt....
McPhee was good and deserved *some* praise, but Simon's praise was over the top. If he had a agenda doing that, it was probably to cement McPhee in the Top 5.