On Dial Idol he is a solid #2 and 3 % above the Pickle. That she's not in the bottom 3 is wrong. Elliott, Paris and McPhee are all better singers, consistantly outsing her and they will all likely to go home before she will.
Elliott is in the bottom three?? The nights early yet. Left coast needs to weigh in.
I don't believe McPhee or Paris consistently outsings her, Elliot always does good but he's a goofy lookin' dude and will be booted off within the next couple weeks. Not because of his voice but because of his image. He isn't Ruben Studdard or Chicken Little enough to get those type of votes. Just like in politics, its not always the positions or platform the candidate takes their image is also a factor.