"The reason most women hate her guts is that she is both pretty and talented. "
You nailed it!! My wife and daughter don't care for her either. They like Pickler better!
And SOME guys don't like her because she's almost too perfect.
And speaking of two.....
I really like Katherine. She is gorgeous & has a beautiful voice. She is missing something though.....passion...soul....personality....she is missing the "thing" that would make her unbeatable. I will continue to vote for her....that doesn't make me a man does it?