| DialIdol Rank |
Idol | DialIdol Score | Margin Of Error | Actual Rank |
| 1-2 | Taylor Hicks | 64.731 | 3.005 | - |
| 1-2 | Kellie Pickler | 63.654 | 3.05 | - |
| 3-6 | Elliott Yamin | 61.115 | 3.155 | - |
| 3-6 | Katharine McPhee | 58.962 | 3.241 | - |
| 3-6 | Chris Daughtry | 58.962 | 3.241 | - |
| 3-6 | Paris Bennett | 55.077 | 3.391 | - |
| 7 | Ace Young | 47.577 | 3.663 |
|
Got through once for Taylor.