[Maximus of Texas]

Max's American Idol Review:

1. Chris - Man, all your songs are sounding alike. You had a chance to really do something different but you stuck with that album rock and its growing old. No votes for you!

2. Elliott - Your first song was good. 2nd one suck. No votes for you.

3. Paris - Good first song. 2nd song was one of the R&B's that have no catchy chorus, just sort of rambles along. No votes for you.

4. Katherine - Wow, you were totally lost on that first song but you rocked on the 2nd and you showed boobage. However, you're not Kellie so no votes for you.

5. Taylor - As always you entertained. Like Simon, I failed to see how the Beatles "Something" can be classified as a current Billboard hit. Overall, I was entertained by you the most. Votes for you.

Paris or Elliott should be voted off tonight but I think Chris needs to be sent a loud and clear message that his microphone stand carting, album rock screaming days need to thrown to the curb. Take a clue from Taylor - stretch a bit. Do something different.

This concludes Max's American Idol Review.

[Netizen]

See #10595

[conservativebabe]

I haven't watched the show yet. Gonna watch it later today. I will give you my response to your review after, good sir.

[ilgipper]

I think Chris has departed from his typical in recent weeks, but returned to it last night. I would like to have seen him do something a little different in one of his two performances to night.

Votes for him, because he blows the rest of these guys away. It is a completely different level of performance. I like several, but he's the only one that I would consider a recording artist. Maybe Paris is 5 years.