No, she hasn't been. She did a poor job on the Crack Ho's song last week, she rolled a really bad one tonight and earned herself a trip to the bottom 3 early on.
But if that were true why did Simon, et al, recant their comments?
But anyway. If you want to put her third for tonight...fine!
She's still a better singer than Taylor and Chris even though I'd like their singing more if i heard it on the radio.