Yikes. McPhee's first song was horrible! If she sang like that in the audition, they would've turned her away.
| Idol | Busy Percent | Actual Rank |
| Taylor Hicks | 91.188 | - |
| Taylor Hicks #2 | 88.161 | - |
| Chris Daughtry | 84.811 | - |
| Katharine McPhee | 80.704 | - |
| Chris Daughtry #2 | 80.077 | - |
| Elliott Yamin | 79.739 | - |
| Katharine McPhee #2 | 77.117 | - |
| Paris Bennett | 75.598 | - |
| Elliott Yamin #2 | 74.972 | - |
| Paris Bennett #2 | 67.015 | - |
| Margin of error: Per Idol; not scientific. | ||