Well, since Aaron Schatz (WTF?) has handed down his truth from on high, I suppose the matter is settled. Stubborn insistence on the truth might seem childlike to you or the great Schatz, but I cannot help that misapprehension.
You should probably capitalize the word "truth" if you have assigned it a meaning other than the commonly understood one. You are now speaking about this game in near-religious terms, as you should since your arguments seem to be motivated by blind Steelers-Fan faith.