I am a lover of the voice, was in choir in HS, and always wanted to be a "singer" when I grew up, as a kid.
What I like about AI as opposed to reality TV is that there is a genuine talent competition going on. I love that the viewers are in control on the winner after the no-talents are weeded out by the judges.
Also, I agree that it is family friendly, for the most part. Aside from the bleeps of some of the rejected, it is all about the singing. The judges are a perfect balance of the kind, the harsh, and the evenly diplomatic.
I'm glad that Idol continues to do well and that it gives some average Joe or Jane, a chance at the big time.
Kelly Clarkson is still enjoying the best outcome, but so far, has been the best talent.
^Great reply, CB :) Thanks for the ping. I've linked this on the Idol thread.