It is a singing competition. They need truthful comments not sweetly slurred crapola.
I think she gives truthful comments. I've heard her tell people they weren't so good. She's not in your face about it like Simon, (and remember, I've said I like Simon too, in fact he's the best one of the judges).
Anyway, we just have a difference of opinion. I'd hate to see her replaced. I seriously doubt she will be. So there really isn't any point to continue this discussion. We'd just be at war on what is suppose to be a fun thread about a fun show. Let's keep it that way:)
Becky