[I'm ALL Right!]

These are my top 6...everyone else can go home.

1. Taylor Hicks...nobody else comes close
2. Chris Daughtry
3. Mandisa
4. Katharine McPhee
5. Elliott Yamin
6. Ace Young

Those are in order...except that I have no preference between Katharine and Elliot. They could switch places in the lineup...six or a half-dozen.

[commish]

I am in complete agreement with your top 5. However, I personally cannot stand Face. Don't like his voice at all. if I had to pick a #6 I guess it would be Lil Magic (Paris) or Lisa.

[BamaDi]

thank you thank you thank you....I love Taylor....and I've got every finger crossed....I think this guy will end up being a true American Idol because of (not only his talent but...) his personality....what a great guy....and oh yeah, he's from ALABAMA....