Cold but accurate. All stats and no rings. Sean Salisbury said the same thing on ESPNEWS.
Did Salisbury say Manning is all stats and no rings, or that he is A-Rod (or did he say both)?
How many rings do you want him to have? How many rings do you think Tom Brady would have if he palyed for the Colts?
Some players have a better supporting cast and better coaches than others. Notice how John Elway could never win the big one until he got a new coaching staff. Tony Dungy is the new Dan Reeves - can build a team to a point but can't get over the hump.
Football is the ultimate team game - Peyton Manning can't go out there and play defense - he has to count on other players. He also can't go out there a run routes or block on the offensive line.