[MikefromOhio]

considering it's only his 2nd year, I think you guys are jumping the gun JUST a bit.

[RedBloodedAmerican]

If the owner of the Giants and Archie didn't think that eli was Super Bowl material, then why did they do what they did to an experienced (super Bowl victorious) veteran like Warner? Would they really think "well, let's just play eli till he's ready"?

Nope; they touted him as the league MVP and they only got what they deserved, IMO.