Yahoo rates it as A-.
Which is odd, because movie reviewers are usually bloodhounds for this sort of thing (Spartacus, every Kevin Smith movie ever made, Top Gun...). But apparently they can't see gay when it... umm, let's not go there.
That's exactly WHY this film is being so "touted" and enthused about by, mostly, homosexuals and agenda-enthusiasts who are also, mostly, those in entertainment media (they rate the films and write the reviews): BECAUSE it's a film that's been expected to be shown and released in neighborhood theatres nationwide, and thus, conditions people into the assumption that homoseuxality on the screen is "normal," usual film fare, the big screen normalacy.
It's an agenda picture in that regard and that's what's got most of Hollywood (same crowd) going about this title. They're finding it marvelous and all that because it's called, "a love story."
It's THEIR concept of "love" unfortunately: deceit, lying, etc.