I think South Park's funniest "Jewish" episode was from the very first seasonThe first Christmas episode was great. When Kyle sang "I'm a Jew, a lonely Jew, at Christmas."
Cartman: "Hey Kyle, Jews can't eat Christmas snow."
Kyle: "Office Barbrady, is it illegal for Jews to eat Christmas snow?"
Officer Barbrady: "Yes!"
Kyle: "Dammit!"
Did the Catholic League post a fatwa against SP for 'The Passion of the Jew' like this episode? I cannot find any outrage like this episode.
For those who don't know, that was an episode making fun of 'The Passion of the Christ'. I believe it was nominated for an Emmy.