If we must have an unqualified crony for SCOTUS I would prefer the chief legal council at Halliburton. Cheney probably "knows his heart" and a nomination like that would have the benefit of making the left go insane. That at least would be fun to watch.
This does not make Meirs qualified. However, in my own mind, we would do well to go outside the ivy league for candidates as often as we can. Our last presidential election seemed like a Yale student council election to me, and when I was in grad school the Yale history faculty was Marxist.