My vote's for Rick. And if someone ever shows him how to tie a necktie, he'd be even better. :)
I've opined on this before: Shepard Smith is an automatic, no-questions-asked channel change for me.
My daughter and her husband watch Shep, and I also watch him ever since I quit watching Matthews way back when. (I think Shep appeals to young people, which is a good thing.) IMO, Shep does a good job with the news. I believe he got stressed out in New Orleans watching those people without food and water for days. That would have been tough for anyone. Britt's the best.