It's probably good that you are a terrible judge of men's looks. ;-)
John Wayne's not bad, actually. Loved him in 'The Quiet Man'. Remember Mike Connors, in 'Mannix'? Same kind of rugged good looks. I was in love with Mannix as a little girl. But, shhhh!, the pc culture has scared away all the rugged men in favor of metrosexuals, and they don't want people to be reminiscing about the rugged men!
I wanted to be Sean Connery as a kid.....for very obvious reasons. LOL