[Charles Henrickson]

(Trivia question: when was the last time BOTH winners came from the same team, in either league?)

Two different guys?
'91-Pendleton and Glavine, Braves

Sometimes one pitcher wins both awards: Willie Hernandez, '84 Tigers; Bob Gibson, '68 Cards. Did Eckersley win both the same year for the A's?

[SpringheelJack]

Did Eckersley win both the same year for the A's?

Yep, and no way did he deserve it.

[raptor29]

1993, Chicago White Sox guys Frank Thomas won the MVP and Jack McDowell won the Cy Young.