I haven't seen "Charlie" yet, because hubby is really balking, (he's very loyal to the Gene Wilder version)although I agree that Depp is very talented. He is one of those actors who can create characters that you remember forever. "Chocolate" and "Finding Neverland" were my favorites.
Now, back on topic (finally!), has anyone suggested that the locket that D and HP retrieved might STILL be a horacrux, just camoflaged by a fake note to make people THINK it wasn't a horacrux any longer?
I hadn't given the locket any thought, really. Whoever RAB turns out to be, most likely R. Black (forgotten his first name!) went through a lot of trouble to get the locket--everything HP and DD went through together. That in itself makes me wonder: How did this RAB do it all alone? Didn't HP give some thought to how it couldn't have been accomplished solo? If that is indeed the case, RAB had an accomplice. Hmmmm....I do think the locket is a fake, though. For some reason, I think the fact that it was opened is significant, but who knows?