Replies

I don't know if i'm replying to the right people..but I sure hope that somehow Snape and Dumbledore had this planned and Snape really is still working for the good side..otherwise, I'll be really dissappointed in the books, which I've loved to this point..I couldn't believe the reason given for Dumbledore trusting Snape was that Snape said he was SORRY? Huh? Surely he's going on more than that..I like the idea that Dumbledore was planning his death much better..

I completely agree with you about DD and Snape--it couldn't have been just a matter of "Sorry I sent the Potters to their deaths, I'll be good from now on, scout's honor!" DD does have a fault in that he always sees the good in others--that's how he knew that Malfoy couldn't (or, at least shouldn't) kill him. I do not think that DD was naive enough to take an apology from Snape and leave it at that.

So, if they did make an Unbreakable Vow or something similar way back when Snape returned repentant, who sealed their vow? My money, if that is the scenario, is on Lupin.