[FreedomPoster]

I wondered who the heck was voting for Scott. I sort of half-watch the show, while FReeping on the couch with the laptop, while my wife watches it.

>>He’s dark, like a singing serial killer or something.

LOL, that's a pretty good summation.

I think pre-teen girls are keeping Anthony in the game. All the other males are too "threatening".

[Ciexyz]

Anthony has improved week after week, and he takes chances with his material. I voted for him this past week (along with Constantine and Bo.) I think all three singers added some spark to the competition.

And I voted for Anthony because I wanted someone who is consistently in the bottom three to get more votes than Scotty.

It doesn't seem fair that Constantine, who had never been in the bottom three before, to get voted off. The rules should be that you have to be in the bottom three for at least one time prior...it gives you time to get your act together and improve, like Bo did when he was in the bottom that one week. He came back swinging.

I am unhappy with the format of Idol in this regard.