Posted on 03/01/2005 7:00:43 PM PST by ProudVet77
Was just watching the special for the last episode. Pretty potent stuff.
A thread to share your thoughts.
I have never seen an Episode. Is/Was it good?
I wonder who will to show their bare a$$ in the finale, it's only fitting they all drop their drawers at once and moon us.
I watched about a half hour of it waiting for an "episode" to start. Then I noticed that they called it "tribute" so I turned it off.
Having grown up in the City and having many friends on the job it was pretty good series. A bit too much with the guns, but overall a well written drama series.
Actually the "tribute" dealt with it dropping pants. But that is actually ancient history in the series. The last several years have gotten much better. Much more character work.
Yeah it was pretty good the first couple of years I watched it, but I can't watch anything for much longer than that.
I know, but I only really watched it in the beginning, it was pretty good.
As a guy who is a bit too fat, a bit too bald and a really poor dresser, I can really connect with Sipowitz.....
I have watched very few series from first episode to last and this was one of them, Hill Street Blues being another. I thought it was great from beginning to end. Without Sipowitz, this drama would never have lasted. There's a big hole on Tuesday evenings now.
I love this show and watched it religiously for years. For a major series its "finality" has been pretty low-key. That, plus the way it ended, makes me wonder if it might not return, maybe in a slightly different form, at a later date.
But if tonight was it, it went out well.
Possibly the greatest NYC TV show of all time. Except for the Odd Couple, of course! And, oh, Kojak, I've got a soft spot for that one too.
Thanks for putting this thread up, I'm really pretty emotional about this whole thing!
Homicide was my favorite show.
What a great show! Yes, it was past its prime. (Then again, Gunsmoke went on for 20 years!) But I still thought it was better than most other shows on TV, even now. (I don't watch much TV, so I may be wrong.)
The Dennis Franz character held his own against "stars" David Caruso and Jimmy Smits, and came to be the absolute center of the series. (I doubt it was planned that way when the show was first created.) The show had its excesses, faults, etc. (sometimes gratuitous "shock value" and repetitive plot lines over the years), but at its best (which was frequently) it was really worthwhile.
I thought the detailed character portrayals were what drove the show. I read a review once that said that Sipowitz (sp?) was the only character you could "smell" on television - he was that real. I thought the most gripping episodes were where his son was killed and he hit bottom. Strong stuff!
To me, the ending left too many things kind of "unresolved." But the creator said that they did not want to go out with a bang. I think his (almost) exact words were that life in the precinct goes on, but we just don't get to visit every week. It's interesting to me how the series both started and ended sort of showing "stories in progress" at the precinct, yet in each case giving a good idea of what came before and would follow later in the lives and careers of the characters.
Of course, it's just a TV show, so there ARE no lives or careers out there to think about. It goes without saying! But the fact that I even think that way shows that the show "got to me" - it was a good show. I will miss it!
To each his own, but I really enjoyed this show. Thanks for starting the thread!
I know what you mean about the ending. I am certain, as certain as I can be, that there will be NO continuation in any form of the show, as one or two posts suggested. I guess we just have to assume he will keep on fighting it out with his superiors, training the new guys (I was almost resentful they got so much screen time!), etc. Life goes on. Maybe the best ending there could be - no ending! A retirement would have been fitting, but I suppose the Sgt. ceremony was Sipowicz's "valedictory" moment. Medavoy's brief visit to the precinct, and his observation that he was indeed gone, was also good. I guess he represents life after the Squad.
Also, some ads I saw promoting the last episode had a couple of short sound bites which weren't in the show, if I'm not mistaken. One of the Chief calling Sipowicz "lieutenant" and one (in another ad) of Sipowitz "kissing goodbye." Maybe they were in the first hour, which I taped but didn't see yet. Maybe they were "red herrings" of some sort. Maybe they were still editing the episode to the last minute. Maybe I am just wrong.
All in all, a great deal of thought put into "just a TV show" on my part. Must seem pretty silly to those who did not see, or did not like, the show. What can I say? :)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.