Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: Basselope
Someone else has already listed their website stuff.

I made one mistake the woman that started this touchy feeling unstructured environment is Dr Montessori.

I would NOT recommend it to anyone. When kids are little they thrive on structure and routine. Montessori strives for the opposite.

I'm not not familiar with the other approach you questioned.

Whatever school you decide on look for one where there IS structure and routine. Kids like this and need this. It helps them feel secure and not at loose ends.

The Montessori environment is not very forgiving. For example if you don't raise your hand you are asked to leave the "circle" at circle time. A friend of mine had her daughter in their school and she was very disappointed with them and took her out. She eventually learned to raise her hand later in the first week at school but there was such an issue made over this by her teacher that she didn't feel comfortable with the lack of grace given to a child as they learn this at 3 years old. Basically she was ostracized for the day.

She also didn't like the lack of structure. When kids come in they're supposed to go to these learning centers and "accomplish" learning tasks. Well when you're 3 or 4 years old they do drift alittle but part of the task of a pre school is to get your child more focused so when they enter school they can sit at their desk, pay attention and lean something useful.

Some parents leave them there for the whole day. They have an area with cots and they turn the lights out so they can nap. Well if the kid doesn't want to nap, they give the child a flashlight to "read" with as others rest.

My brush with them was amusing. I called them for a tour of their facility. Well it seems that no time they had available suited us and I also wanted to go there unannounced to see what they really do - they don't permit that. It was frustrating and I thought they were very snotty. I'm glad we didn't go there.
20 posted on 02/18/2005 10:16:13 AM PST by nmh (Intelligent people recognize Intelligent Design (God).)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


To: nmh

With all due respect, your opinion of Montessori is based on a very isolated experience, and also seems to be a rather misinformed one as well. As a certified Montessori educator at the primary (preschool) level, I can tell you it is certainly not due to Montessori's teachings or beliefs that a child would be ostracized EVER, or excluded or singled out in any way.
As for the teachers being snotty, that certainly sounds like something unique to their individual personalities, and not necessarily present in all Montessori educators.
To say that Montessori is touchy feely is grossly inaccurate. And after having taught in traditional preschool settings for nearly a decade before switching to Montessori, I can tell you there is more structure and order in that environment than in any preschool or traditionally taught classroom. The only difference is that the discipline and structure is not tyrannically imposed by the teacher, yet there is a modeling of respect, conflict resolution in a pro-social way, and fun...yes, dare I say FUN in a Montessori environment. That being said, there is the expectation to adhere to ground rules and complete the work cycle fully. This is meant to increase the sense of order, concentration, coordination and independence that are so crucial to success in a more traditional setting (i.e. children expected to sit at a desk).
To say that Montessori is void of structure and routine is simply ignorant. Montessori is based on the premise of repetition and honoring the child's sensitive periods of development. You talk of children being expected to "accomplish" learning tasks. In a true Montessori environment, the children are not expected to accomplish tasks without first having a one on one or small group lesson.
As for not allowing you to drop in, our Montessori school has an open door policy, as should any preschool. If they don't, it is perhaps best to seek another environment. That is not Montessori's way, so it is unfair to attribute that one school's policy to Montessori. It sounds like you had a bad experience with a preschool who is misrepresenting the Montessori name/philosophy. Please do everyone a service by refraining from applying those bad traits isolated to that school to Montessori in general. That is merely close-minded, and serves to perpetuate misunderstanding and intolerance.


46 posted on 08/28/2005 7:54:36 PM PDT by pinctower
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson