(Vanity) If it's between McCain or Giuliani, who will you choose?

[Patriot814]

I know the 2008 election is a while away and anything could happen, but if things were the same as the polls right now and it was between McCain and Giuliani, who would you choose? I would choose Giuliani because they're both modereate, but Giuliani's more loyal. McCain would appease the democrats and would be painted as crazy.

[John Lenin]

I'm tired of playing the lesser of two evils game. If Rudy or McCain is what's left I'm voting 3rd party because I will have no part in the GOP loss.

[Ditter]

I agree with you on Newt, he is a brilliant speaker but the choice here tonight is Mc Cain or Rudy. Rudy wins my vote.

[FDNYRHEROES]

Let's take it one game at a time. Patriots, of course...

[NorCalRepub]

not really.......many people here have different Ideas of what a RINO really is......for some if they disagree on one single issue they are RINO's even though they thought them great a week ago......for instance....Bush is a RINO correct?....is non war spending is not conservative and he want illegal alien amnesty.....so is Bush a RINO too...? I would agree with you on Spector, Snowe, Chaffee and Collins but not the others.......

[RasterMaster]

Jeb & Condi....another Bush just to rub the dems faces in it!

[NorCalRepub]

that of course is your choice....most Republican Presidents and pundits want us to have a bigger inclusive tent but you of course don't have to go along with it.......I understand

[Don Carlos]

If those two were my only choice, I'd buy a case of Scotch and stay home!

[John Lenin]

And some people go down with the ship, not me. LOL What was the #! issue with most voters ? Values, if the GOP runs a RINO the fix is in , Hitlery wins.

[Happygal]

If Rudy is a good conservative, he will take Hillary's senate seat in '06.

If she can't hold a seat in the senate, she can't run a presidential campaign.

[birbear]

As far as Guiliani, the 2nd Amendment matters!

I'm not entirely familiar with Guiliani's 2nd Amedment stances, but I would guess that his views would change somewhat between running NYC and running the country.

Pro-gun control works well as a policy in a large urban area (this is where I get inundated with NRA statistics...that's not my point... it works wells as a policy to get votes.)

Guiliani is (I hope) smart enough to realize that he would have to be more pro 2nd amendment to be considered as a realistic candidate for pres, if he so chose to run.

Basically, in a nut shell... stricter gun control policies make sense when you're running a larger urban area. They don't make as much sense when you're running a country with lots of rural area.

[Happygal]

I pick South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford!

Sanford '08.

[John Lenin]

Rudy is a gun grabber, if the GOP wants to go back to the minority, start running RINO'S on a national level.

[madison10]

I won't vote.

[NeoCaveman]

If Rudy is a good conservative, he will take Hillary's senate seat in '06.

But Rudy is in no way a conservatve.

[NeoCaveman]

You haven't told me all the info
Who are the Dems running?
Who are the goofy third parties running?
Because I certainly need more choices than Rudy or McKeating.

[Happygal]

I know that.
But in NYC terms, he'll take a seat from Hitlery.

[PzLdr]

Neither.

[UncleDick]

Between those two, I'll go 3rd party.

[NeoCaveman]

I know that. But in NYC terms, he'll take a seat from Hitlery.

I'd love to see him run against Hillary for the Senate seat but in a way you already told us what is going to happen

you wrote: If Rudy is a good conservative, he will take Hillary's senate seat in '06.

He isn't, so he won't run.

I'm calling it right now, Rudy v. Hillary 2006 will not happen.

[John Lenin]

The GOP better not ask me for any money if they promote Rudy.