Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: lonestar67
Nope. PC problems are more serious than administrator settings. PCs are cheaper. They generally use parts that fail more easily. I have seen many more screen failures, power packs, and battery failures on PCs than on Macs.

Reality check: There are plenty of examples of Macs turning into hotplates, frying their batteries, etc. I love the anecdote about Macs potentially exploding. Oh, yeah. There's real quality control there. Nice. /SARCASM

Apple recalls overheating batteries
Apple recalls power adapters
Cubes suck ass
What can I do about my overheating Titanium PowerBook G4?

Macs have always had a problem with power management and heat. Some things never change.

The notebooks I am referring to are not lab computers-- though I am familiar with that setting as well. The personal notebook computers of students do not work. Answers to my post show that if PCs are shared they become even more vulnerable.

Duh. They're being run in Administrator mode. Of course they're vulnerable to these dumbass kids installing crapware on them. They shouldn't be run in anything other than a Restricted account.

Macs have administrator settings which I do use. But even when Macs lack administration authorizations, they tend to fail and be corrupted less (in my 10 years of experience at this university).

Statistically, there are far fewer of them. Hence, your anecdotal "evidence" is based on skewed averages.

IT support is in a racket with Windows/Microsoft-- let's admit it.

Many IT shops are simply incompetent. Yours is no exception.
280 posted on 02/05/2005 11:28:54 AM PST by Bush2000
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 278 | View Replies ]


To: Bush2000

PC users are sovereign rational and Mac users are fanatics. Mac users have no grip on reality. I understand. This has been explained to me by dozens of PC advocates.

Nonetheless, since your last post, yet another grad student told me-- my power pack for my PC broke (the second time in six months); can I take you Mac notebook to do my work on this trip. I said yes. The company that was to provide the new power pack emailed him to tell him that despite the promised delivery this week it might actually be several weeks before they could deliver a replacement power pack.

A few years ago my PC friends told me Gateways were vastly superior computers. Now they say they are junk and Dells are awesome. I actually do think that Dells are the best PCs-- probably the only brand worth risking. Nonetheless, the Apple products are consistently more reliable (in my limited years of experience with dozens of computers in labs and personal situations).

What is also strange to me is that in the years of having these debates, the Apple users are rhetorically constructed as irrational. I gather that because the market share is so small (which is its own bizarre distortion-- but I will not pursue that topic) Apple users must obey their PC counterpart insistence that they buy PCs. Actually, we don't have to agree to this insistence, and Apple can continue making money hand over fist by selling quality computers to people who prefer them over PCs. This may in part explain why Apple is one of the fastest rising stocks on the market.


281 posted on 02/05/2005 2:27:25 PM PST by lonestar67
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 280 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson