[lt.america]

I would concede Vick is having a "good" year, but 13 TDs to 12 INTs isn't exactly great and the NFL is saying these are Pro Bowl stats.

[F16Fighter]

"Vick is having a 'good' year, but 13 TDs to 12 INTs isn't exactly great and the NFL is saying these are Pro Bowl stats."

On THAT basis, 13/12 is NOT 'Pro Bowl' stuff, and the Vick selection appears to be "style over substance."

OTOH, even IF stats are to be transcended by "charisma" and "presense," then why in the world is Favre not there?

[staytrue]

Vick is having a "good" year, but 13 TDs to 12 INTs isn't exactly great

There are a lot of qb's with better arms, but Vick, McNabb bring the extra dimension of being a dangerous running back too and that is where Farve is behind. But you did not post running stats or sacks, or rushing first downs.