Right now, I'd happily give away this Gerber, or the Schrade, depending on where the best deals were at the time. I have no reservations about either knife, while there are several things about the Kershaw that give me pause. We'd have the "pocket knife" situation nailed down with these two. It's just a matter of looking around, and seeing if a great deal on a "working knife" pops up again. But I can't think of any GI who wouldn't be happy with one of these guys.
My next step is to buy large enough quantities of one or both, so I can have some inventory on hand. And I have to still keep an eye out for any great deal on a bigger knife that might happen along.
We may wind up with 2-4 different knives that we give out, depending on how good we've been in catching the deals.