I shot a housecat at 100 yards by accident
On the last day of the hunt, the guide went out to pick up the hunters, and one of them told the guide excitedly, "I got one! I couldn't tell how big he was, but I'm pretty sure it was a good shot!"
The guide told him that he'd go out and look for the bear later and they went back to the lodge.
The next day, when telling the story, the guide was heard to say, "Well, I went out and found it...and it was the biggest damned racoon I've ever seen"