Posted on 08/01/2026 8:46:41 AM PDT by ProtectOurFreedom
This is one of the most beloved paintings in America, and it puts its finger on something we all pass through, first as the child, and one day as the parent left behind...
The painting is Breaking Home Ties<, by Norman Rockwell, on the cover of the Saturday Evening Post in 1954. A father and his teenage son sit side by side on the running board of a battered farm truck, waiting at a railway stop. A single track runs along the bottom of the picture. A ticket pokes from the boy's pocket. His suitcase is stacked with schoolbooks and wears a "State U" pennant. The train is coming to carry him off to college, away from home, for the first time in his life.
Everything is in the way they sit.
The son sits upright, scrubbed and dressed in his best, eyes fixed on the horizon, on the track, on the future rushing toward him. He is already half gone. For him that train is the beginning of everything.
His father sits beside him in worn work clothes and scuffed boots, looking the other way, down the line, as if he cannot bear to watch it arrive. The same train means the opposite thing to him. For the son it is the start of a life. For the father it is the day the house grows quieter, the chair at the table sits empty, and the person he built his world around walks out into a life that no longer has him at its centre.
Look at his hands. He is holding two hats. His own battered one, and resting on top of it, his son's crisp new one, held carefully together, because it is the last small thing he can still do for the boy...
And then the dog, its head laid in the son's lap, gazing up, refusing to look away. Rockwell knew exactly what that was for: "The father couldn't show how he felt about the boy's leaving," he said. "The dog did."
It has moved people for 70 years because every leaving is a beginning for one person and an ending for another. The child steps out into the world, as they should. And someone stays behind, watching them go, and loving them enough to let them go anyway...
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
I cannot almost read it, through the tears.
The author did seem to miss, though, the lunch from Mom, tied carefully, and in his lap. I expect that she could not even bear to be there.
read STONER. An very under appreciated book about this very picture and the aftermath.
If you look closely, the boy has his father’s hands.
To my mind, the father’s hands and the dog are the best parts of the painting, but the boots shouldn’t be so shiny. He’s a farmer after all. The cluelessness of the kid’s face comes as a close second.
Rockwell certainly had the feel for working people.
Those hands belong to the land on which he grew, the joints enlarged by brutal manual labor. He'll have arthritis there someday if he doesn't have it already.
Rockwell knew what he was doing. I try to keep my boots shiny, just so they’ll last. Water destroys leather easily. Look at the Dad’s pants.
Just my perspective, and best to you.
Rockwell recorded history... The best artist always do.
Could be his Sunday go to meeting boots.
I guess that distinction might be regional and/or temporal. My logging boots get oiled, but they're never shiny. Those look similar to cowboy boots one wouldn't find on a farmer, but that might be different in the early 20th Century where one would still find horses on the farm.
Don't know. It's just the impression it made on me.
I thought I'd add to the thread my standards for great art (which this piece certainly meets)
The painting—which depicts an elderly woman and a young boy bowing their heads in prayer inside a bustling, crowded diner while other patrons look on—resonated deeply with audiences for its quiet, emotional warmth.
It became one of the most highly valued of his works when it sold at a Sotheby's auction for a record-setting $46 million.
Wait until a daughter gets married.
This is great to read about. Now that I’m 65 I can more appreciate it. Thanks for posting.
The son would more likely affix a “State U.” sticker on his luggage after starting school, which might point toward an older brother having attended and the case was handed down.
I always loved that painting. He was so good.
Using a horse for farming may also be regional or temporal. I was noticing that Dad’s boots looked like riding boots and not the farming boots that I have. (The toe). I am not sure how using the leather may impact its shine.
The painting makes me want to look for some Norman Rockwell to replace the Ansel Adams photos around my house.
Publically, Rockwell considered himself an illustrator, rather than an artist...
Yes, very touching!
Dogs know
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.