Clear Testimony VS I. Gershoni’s (rosy attempted, propaganda) Narrative (on Arab Muslims in the Holy land during WW2 & Nazi radio)

Compiled book excerpt + Grok

[Freeleesy]

The following is an excerpt from a book translated into English:

Arbel, Tobi. The Story of Muhammad Abu Sarari (Heb.). Israel, Ra'anana: Docostory, 2000.
link

From the events of '36, I have a childhood memory. Then the gangs were active and terrorized the Jews. The one who organized them was Hassan Salama. The gang members wanted to cause harm to the Jews who bought agricultural goods from the Arabs. They would lie in wait in the wadis and on the roads for Arab merchants who smuggled vegetables and fruit to the Hatikva market. If they caught the smugglers, they would beat them, throw their goods at them, and the poor people would return home without the money and without the goods. The ones who benefited from all this were us children.
We collected everything that was left in the field and brought it home. I still remember from that time, every day at 9:30 a.m. someone would come with a bicycle and bring newspapers from Egypt. He would also come to Beit Dagon and sell newspapers. I was six years old, but I couldn't read. My brother would read and I would hear what was happening in the world, but I didn't always understand these politics. Even though I didn't go to school, I was always curious and I loved to learn.

Of all the brothers, I was the closest to my father. He would take me everywhere, even to pray. I learned a lot from that, because I saw a lot. There would be 50-100 people praying in the mosque. I remember the imam delivering sermons and praying for the victory of Abu Ali. Abu Ali is Hitler. So that the English, who ruled the country at the time and were Hitler's opponents, would not understand who they were talking about, the Arabs called Hitler: Abu Ali.
The Arabs were very afraid that they would be heard speaking admiringly about Hitler, in mosques and cafes, and would accuse them of collaborating with the Germans.

And that is what happened to our imam. Shortly after his sermon in favor of Hitler, the British arrested him and imprisoned him without trial.

At that time, incitement and attacks on Jews began. The Mufti, Hajj Amin al-Husseini, who was one of the leaders of the instigators against the Jews, was arrested by the British.

Page 19:

I saved myself half a penny a week to buy myself a horse drink, a wonderful drink made from brown grasses that grow in the wadi. It was very tasty, today it is only available in Gaza. Games? Mischief? I had no time to play with children. You could say that I had no childhood, no cinema, no entertainment, nothing.

I worked in this cafe for two years, and I only had two days off.

During the war, the British prevented the Arabs in the country from listening to Berlin radio. When the British discovered that they were listening to this radio, they would close the cafe for three months. But in the cafe where I worked, they listened to Berlin radio, and I, the little one, looked out for the British police.

Hassan Abu-Havila, the owner of the cafe, asked me to sit outside, in the dark, to warn them if the police came, who would patrol the street every evening.

Two Arab policemen and an English policeman. (In the Jewish towns, two Jewish policemen and an English policeman used to go around.) The Arabs listened to Radio Berlin, because they thought that only it spoke the truth. They were sure that what the Americans were saying was a lie. Most Arabs in Israel were in favor of Nazi Germany. The Arabs also listened to Radio Turkey. There was no prohibition on that, even though Turkey was with the Germans. The policemen were locked in shoes with irons in the soles, and so I could hear them coming from afar.

---

Next, I presented this as a question to GROK VS (biased) Wikipedia citing I. Gershoni 2014 book, whereby he cites a 1943 British poll of radio listeners.

GROK REPLIED

Muhammad Abu Sarari’s Testimony Inpact and I. Gershoni’s Narrative

Source: Arbel, Tobi. The Story of Muhammad Abu Sarari. Ra’anana: Docostory, 2000 (Hebrew). Oral testimony of Muhammad Abu Sarari (b. ~1930, Yazur village near Jaffa).

Key Excerpts from the Testimony

“During the war, the British prevented the Arabs in the country from listening to Berlin radio… But in the cafe where I worked, they listened to Berlin radio, and I, the little one, looked out for the British police.”

“The Arabs listened to Radio Berlin, because they thought that only it spoke the truth… Most Arabs in Israel were in favor of Nazi Germany.”

“I remember the imam delivering sermons and praying for the victory of Abu Ali. Abu Ali is Hitler… Shortly after his sermon in favor of Hitler, the British arrested him and imprisoned him without trial.”

Why This Testimony Undermines Gershoni’s Thesis

Israel Gershoni and others argue that Palestinian Arab (and Egyptian) public opinion turned decisively against the Axis and toward the Allies by 1942–1943. A frequently cited piece of evidence is a 1943 British intelligence survey of radio listening habits in Palestine that supposedly showed the BBC Arabic service far ahead of Radio Berlin/Zeesen.

Muhammad Abu Sarari’s firsthand account directly contradicts this picture:

• Time period: Explicitly World War II (“during the war”). Abu Sarari was ~9–15 years old — old enough to be employed as a café lookout.
• Routine secrecy: Arabs in Jaffa cafés and villages systematically hid their listening to Radio Berlin, posted child lookouts, risked severe punishment (café closed for 3 months).
• Widespread pro-Axis sympathy: Mosque prayers for Hitler (“Abu Ali”), imam imprisoned for pro-Hitler preaching, general statement that “most Arabs” supported Nazi Germany.
• Implication for the 1943 poll: When listening to Berlin radio could land you in jail or destroy your business, no one would openly admit it to a British surveyor. Any poll conducted under those repressive conditions was bound to produce heavily self-censored, unreliable results.

Conclusion

The testimony of a single village boy who spent his evenings listening for the clack of British police boots is far more credible, under the circumstances, than a British intelligence survey taken in an atmosphere of fear and repression. It demonstrates that pro-Axis sentiment and clandestine listening to Radio Berlin remained common in at least parts of the Palestinian Arab population well into the war years — exactly the opposite of what Gershoni and the 1943 poll are claimed to prove.

One child’s memoir from Yazur does serious damage to the narrative that Palestinian Arab society had “largely abandoned the Axis” by 1943.

---

TOPICS: History; Politics
KEYWORDS: abusarari; abusarrari; arabnazis; arabs; getmrshoni; israel; israelgershoni; mandatorypalestine; muslims; poll; wikibias; wikipedia; ww2

[Words Matter]

Wow. Kudos. Quite a research. The Brits also controlled and censored the Arab press during the war.

[Netz]

Bottom line: the Arab masses, now called PALEOstinians supported Hitler via their Mufti in order to oust the British and slaughter the remaining Jews.

Funny how lies continue in their distorted minds. They committed atrocities, pogroms, genocide from 1919 to the present. Yet they transfer all their guilt and evil onto their victims...the Jews.

The truth means nothing to the Arabs.