Posted on 08/11/2024 4:51:09 AM PDT by Ozguy1945
Dear Freeper Sportslovers,
Does this Australian Rules football hit, which caused permanent brain damage to Angus Brayshaw, look like "A Football Act" or criminal assault?
One commentator said Maynard, the player wearing black and whit stripes, couldn't stop.
Another said he had a duty of care to himself to rotate his own body to avoid behind hurt by colliding from above with Brayshaw's head.
Under the rules of the game 18.3.2 (c). it is illegal to make high contact to an opposition player with any part of the body.
Under 18.3.2 (f) makes it illegal to charge at an opposition player.
In my opinion Brayden Maynard charged at Angus Brayshaw and made a collision inevitable.
Brayshaw retired prematurely. His club gave him an off field leadership role but he was unable to do it.
His life is ruined.
Modern awareness of how damaging concussion can be will force changes.
Ozguy1945
Yes, the heart type stuff is weird when you are young and first hear about teen sports stars dying but the exertion exposes those things, in my case it was a blow that caused the damage which is sad also, but rare.
It is all part of the natural process to weed out the weak which in a modern society doesn’t serve any purpose like it would in a society of warfare but young males need to do what they have to do and dying doing rough stuff that you like isn’t so bad, especially if it resulted from a hidden physical flaw that didn’t match your aggressive spirit for life anyway.
I imagine you are
Think of the old days just leather helmets and shirt pads
You still in Japan or back in NorCal?
Interesting bio
I had a friend in 80s played AFL
wild man
We worked globally
He lived on drinking and benzos
Rough on girls not physical just very harsh but some loved it lol
Agreed. Even a professional athlete can only do so much while in mid-air at full speed. Terrible indeed, but it doesn’t look any more deliberate than many other collisions in a rough contact sport at this level of play.
It’s not much of a bio, but it’s true.
I don’t know why the guy in black and whitebwas jumping up? It looks like he was in the air before the other guy kicked the ball, so it wasn’t because he was trying to catch or block the ball high in the air, as the ball went low.
Overall, it looks to me like the guy did just jump onto the other guy.
But I know nothing about rugby!
Doesn’t even look like an especially hard hit. Nothing that looks malicious.
I’m discussing AFL now and this hit with Aussie mate on our beer night in Tokyo. I couldn’t remember the details of the story, but fortunately I commented, so I could find the article.
My mate thought I must talking about Jason Winderlich, but we got it sorted now.
Looks like an accident to me.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.