Posted on 04/22/2020 9:40:46 AM PDT by USA Conservative
They do exist but they are costly. Ammo for small cannons and machine guns is cheap.
One “smart” shell versus 10,000 dumb bullets? Where’s the economic cross-over point?
I can see the logic of giving sailors shooting practice with dumb bullets, though. That’s an area where you don’t want OJT to be the rule of the day.
Plywood gives a poor radar return. And there is no one in the pod to act as a backup when the target is a fuzzy blob on the screen, even if the targeting computer is working correctly, and an electrical connection hasn't been jarred loose by an RPG impact. Is there even such a thing as a visual target director, any more? Not for a Mach 4 incoming vampire, but a jihadi in a CrisCraft?
It would be sorta nice to have a FLIR system, hooked to a screen, and some gunner that can override the targeting to take out close in surface traffic. It might be worthy of a news story to watch a US Navy ship in harbor, and the CWIS pods are tracking passing pleasure craft... Just for practice...
After Pearl Harbor, it was apparent that the US Navy had blown off damage control as a vital training drill. With modern systems, does a captain unplug a vital component, and THEN have a Damage Control drill?
Better radar today & better signal processing but false positives are still a fact of life.
* The navy has also been developing laser weapons, which would be ideal for this application. *
There *might* be a pre-production model of the ODIN laser system in the Gulf right now, but until the Flight III Burke destroyers start appearing in commission only 1 or 2 destroyers coming out of refit will have them. I’ve seen reports that USS Dewey (DDG-105) is equipped with ODIN. But the Gulf is a big place and the Iranians will have the advantage of choosing their initial targets and the timing of the attack.
My battle station was first loader on a 5"-38 naval gun. While we never fired a shot in anger (I served 1961-64; my "war" was the Cuban Missile Crisis) we did drill from time to time. At sea when we drilled for battle our targets were 55 gallon steel drums with one end weighted and a sheet of radar reflective metal standing up on the other end. A tiny target from a half mile or more. Not a moving target, though. But most shots (radar directed or "seat of the pants") hit close enough that a small vessel would have been damaged.
Seems to me that what we should be using are cluster shells.
That one's above my pay grade!
Well, when the navy and general dynamics were developing this system, a phalanx sucessfully hit a drone at approx 2500 feet from the test platform, then proceded to vary its aim until all the pieces decending were broken down into about 6 inch chunks. so imagine an airplane that was just hit the gun keeps firing until there are small chunks and a pilot hanging from a parachute. major pucker factor. and, yes there are manual target designaters.
Is it capable of other uses? Can it depress enough to hit a small boat, close aboard, say within 100 yards, in a port? Can it's radar pick out a plywood or even rubber boat in heavy seas with spoofed returns? A visually aimed system can, and without spray-n-pray expending ammo.
And to ADVERTISE this, so that some Iranian sailor KNOWS that if he gets within range, he's going to be unidentified flaked fish food. One BRRT! and he's a greasy spreading slick on the ocean.
Knowing is a powerful deterrent. To KNOW that some 19 year old infidel gets all tickly in the nethers at the thought of minced Iranian. You don't tug on Superman's cape...
Can A-10 Warthogs be launched from a carrier? The Warthos would make them pay. Sink everyone of them. Go Navy.
Warthogs. I got big fingers.
Try searching youtube, “phalanx”.
Try searching youtube, phalanx.
****
And Naval Artillery such as the turreted 5” rapid fire guns.
I was wondering what everyone was talking about then watched the video.
Absolutely incredibly bad shooting.
Great version!
Sheesh, watch the vid.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.